
An incredible accomplishment, “Charity and Sylvia” offers an artful telling of a lesbian couple’s life together in 1800s Vermont.
The story is captured in journal-like vignettes chronicling the life of Charity Bryant and Sylvia Drake from their first meeting. Charity has come from Massachusetts with an air of scandal; Sylvia is the maiden aunt of a large farming family, used to hard work and childcare. Soon after the two connect, they take up lodging in a rented room that also serves as Charity’s seamstress shop. From there, they build a life together for more than 40 years.
It isn’t totally idyllic. To say nothing of the ceaseless labor that’s required to sustain them, they face judgment from loved ones and an unrelenting need to conceal the true nature of their relationship. But in the end, they’re accepted, for the most part, serving as pillars of the community, leading church groups and Sunday school.
Richly illustrated, Walden’s graphic novel is an impressive act of historic fiction. The drudgery of the fields and the stiffness of the clothing are ably captured. Her characters and their personalities are detailed as well. Charity is boisterous and intemperate; Sylvia is quieter and more conventional, an anchor to her loved ones.
The book explores the characters’ faith, particularly Sylvia. Church is a cornerstone of their community, and both partners face fears about the eternal consequences of their lives together. But these worries are balanced by their joys together, the laughter of gossip and tiny pranks, and the book does a good job addressing their concerns about damnation without wallowing in them.
Charity and Sylvia also have ample cause to live for today, as the book takes place during a time when death is sudden and commonplace. Walden builds real feeling for a large cast, and readers will get the gut-punch of death scenes that would be at home in “Little House on Prairie.”
Charity’s family in particular is haunted by untimely loss..so how could she do anything other than make the most of what life she has available to her? Walden captures a hard time and manages to wring something close to a miracle from it. It’s a wonderful book, engrossing and real.